Tool sharpening, type of grinders and stones (2024)

C

Chris Sandberg

Aluminum
Joined
Mar 18, 2008
Location
Portland, Oregon
  • Nov 10, 2008
  • #1

Hello Group, I have a Question on sharpening HSS and Carbide on steel tools. I did a search but did not find the exact explanation I was after. I have HSS cutting blanks and soldered on carbide cutters and want to get the grinding and finishing stone needed to make and resharpen tools for steel and aluminum. I have the shape charts I just need the equipment to get going.
A newbie/ beginner
TX in advance ChrisTool sharpening, type of grinders and stones (1)

E

eng4turns

Aluminum
Joined
Jan 21, 2008
Location
Kissimmee, Florida
  • Nov 10, 2008
  • #2

HSS takes aluminum oxide wheels. The grayish blue is fine (try Norton). Don't buy the cheapies for your tool grinding. Don't use the white or pink for this. Get a couple of grades, medium and fine. Rough out blanks on your bench grinder by hand, then go over to your good tool grinding wheels.

For carbide, you must use one of these three: diamond, green silicon carbide, or silicon boride (I don't think I got that last one right bit it's something like that and they are very expensive). While you can wear an aluminum oxide wheel down on carbide and eventually do something, it will not be what you want. So buy a green wheel to start with mounted on a standard bench grinder. Eventually, you will realize this is not an ideal setup and your tool performance will lag your expectations so you'll then want to get a tool grinder where you grind on the face of the wheel, not outer periphery. Typically anywhere from $160 at Horror Freight to $300 at ENCO. Bought mine at HF on sale for $130, came with two green wheels. BTW, I took one of the green wheels off my HF tool grinder and made up an aluminum wheel that I impregnate with diamond paste - the kind you get in little syringes. After the green wheel for roughing, the diamond wheel hone puts a super fine edge on the carbide.

You will need to get a diamond dressing point for both types and make up a holder so you can dress the wheels. Wear a dust mask and don't do this near your lathes and mills.

Buy enough grinders so you can dedicate grinders to certain sharpening tasks. Set up one grinder with your two HSS sharpening wheels, make up grinding guides and blocks with your usual preferred angles and then you'll find that sharpening and honing up is a trivial task.

If you get a tool grinder for your carbide, dedicate it only to that.

Ed in Florida

M

mygoatboy

Aluminum
Joined
May 12, 2007
Location
Sterling, MA
  • Nov 10, 2008
  • #3

I will second that about getting almost no where trying to grind carbide without the proper wheel. I do it in a pinch but you take more material from the wheel than you do from the carbide.

A

AndrewM

Plastic
Joined
Sep 8, 2008
Location
Waco TX
  • Nov 10, 2008
  • #4

Warning: newbie question.

I bought one of those Baldor-style Harbor Freight tool grinders (parking lot sale, $95 Tool sharpening, type of grinders and stones (2)) with the green wheels. I've been using it for HSS. Honestly, they've been working fine for me. Is there something I'm missing? Would I get a better surface finish if I were to use a finer (AO?) wheel? I've seen the threads over on HSM about the other style wheels and where to get them, but haven't done so yet.

I was impressed with the HF grinder though, mine runs very smoothly and is very quiet (when not making sparks, of course). Not a typical "use the cord as a leash while it walks around the shop" HF grinder.

S

stnecut

Hot Rolled
Joined
Nov 5, 2008
Location
Massachusetts, USA
  • Nov 10, 2008
  • #5

Green Wheels

Green silicon carbide wheels is what we used to shape our carbide tipped tools in a natural limestone mill I used to work in. They always performed well. You should get a dressing wheel if you use them on a bench grinder though. You'll find it very helpful in bringing the wheel back to shape. Remember your respirator while working with them.

C

Chris Sandberg

Aluminum
Joined
Mar 18, 2008
Location
Portland, Oregon
  • Nov 10, 2008
  • #6

Sharpening, type of grinders and stones

Hello Group, Thanks for the exact info I was after but I still was wondering about a final polishing stone for the very end of the job. Is there such a thing, I was under the impression that you finish on a hand stone for the very edge of the cutter for razor sharp.
a newbie/ beginner
TX ChrisTool sharpening, type of grinders and stones (3)

M

Mike C.

Diamond
Joined
Nov 25, 2004
Location
Birmingham, AL
  • Nov 11, 2008
  • #7

White stones are ideal for HSS, but need to be operated at the proper speed. They can be expensive and hard to find for a typical bench grinder. If you can find them, go for it. They are very good and don't burn the tool as badly as gray wheels.

The biggest help in fast forming of tools is a big honking grinder. I have a 1750rpm 1hp Cincy at home that will eat a bushhog blade as hard as you can push it without bogging. It makes real short work of shaping a 3/8" lathe tool. I have a coarse wheel on one side (60grit Bay state gray wheel) and a very fine wheel on the other (I think it's a 180grit brown/tan colored wheel by Norton, leaves a beautiful polished edge). I hone my tools after grinding. The more polished the edge, the better your finish.

Now for carbide. Green wheels will cut carbide, but from the experience several of us had at the scraping seminar in Savannah, GA a couple of years back, it is akin to sharpening your knife by rubbing it on the driveway. The resulting edge is chipped and ragged, and this will show up in your work. Green wheels are fine for roughing, but diamond is the ticket for a good sharp edge.

The green wheels (silicon carbide) are no good for steel. They combine with the steel and do bad things, as well as disappear at a rapid rate. Same for diamond, but in the other direction... the steel kills the diamond.

J

J. Randall

Stainless
Joined
Jul 29, 2003
Location
Vici Okla. U.S.A.
  • Nov 11, 2008
  • #8

AndrewM, I think I have read that the Harbor Freight grinder come with green colored wheels, but they are really aluminum oxide. If that is the case that is why the work good on hss, plus some people grind their hss on a silicon carbide wheel even though it is not whats recommended.
On another note if you have not tried grinding your hss tools on a belt grinder you should, its faster and for me easier to get the angles right.
James

C

calvin b

Hot Rolled
Joined
Nov 29, 2007
Location
E-burg MD USA
  • Nov 11, 2008
  • #9

Chris,
Practice and notes on what works.. grinding hss is sorta of an art.. I use an Arkansas stone to final finish my hss.. it really does make a difference in how long I can cut and what the final finish is... As for carbide... I have yet to find any that works as well as hss on my south bend h10... Just my experience.
Hope that helps
Calvin
PS Somewhere on this sight I found a little primer on tool griding that was most helpful but I can't seem to find it now... I have a copy of it hung above my grinder..

C

Clive603

Diamond
Joined
Aug 2, 2008
Location
Sussex, England
  • Nov 11, 2008
  • #10

Chris

A good grinding rest with decent size table is a great help. If you are on a budget consider something like this:-
http://www.axminster.co.uk/product.asp?pf_id=21251&name=Grinding+Rest&user_search=1&sfile=1&jump=0
or possibly this:-
http://www.axminster.co.uk/product.asp?pf_id=22615&name=Grinding+Rest&user_search=1&sfile=1&jump=0
Your local cheapy chinee merchant will have something similar, expect to do a bit of post delivery rectification.

I got one of the first mentioned ones as a "cheap'n cheerful, will do for now" solution pending getting my Clarkson T&C grinder up'n running. Works well enough although the ally table is a bit rough in the surface so tools don't slide too well. If it were an an "all I have" keeper I'd put smooth 10 gauge steel plates on top. Worth making templates to set the angles you use. I use a cup wheel so I'm grinding on a flat face and can simply set the first one with a machinists protractor then use the tool itself to replicate the angles. Templates better if you use a normal wheel and grind on the periphery.

Normal v cup is pretty much six of one, half a dozen of the other for basic lathe tool grinding. Grinding on the periphery gives a hollow ground shape to the edges so its easier to touch up with a slip stone as much less material has to be removed. Conversely the stone is much less stable so its easy to round off the sharp corner. I don't use one but there is much to be said for having the slip in an angled holder so you can hold the tool down on a flat surface and slide the slip past with it firmly supported at the right angle.

If you use tool bits in Armstrong style holders make one of the SouthBend style grinding jigs which make it very easy to replicate the right angles. I'm sure someone here has links to a design, if not I have something somewhere.

If you've not already got adequate drill sharpening kit the simple swing across the wheel types work well once you figure out the knack.

Should you later venture into milling and need to sharpen milling cutters remember there are several simplified for home use designs of tool and cutter grinder around varying from very basic but good for a limited range of jobs to close to commercial capabilities with corresponding complexity in the build. Come back and ask if the need arises.

Note that you will get best results if the sharpener starts at the edge to be sharpened and moves into the main material. Going the other way leaves a tiny wire edge which is very difficult to shift whilst keeping a really keen edge.

Belt sanders are good for rough shaping, as James says it can be a lot easier to see the angles. However I find that its still necessary to touch up on the grinder before honing as the belt leaves too much surface roughness for the slip to deal with in reasonable time. Excellent alternative to a coarse wheel though and saves working you fine wheel too hard. After the preliminary shaping a coarse wheel is pretty much a waste of space and swopping wheels around should be minimised as you pretty much always have to re-dress. Wasteful and messy, especially if you don't have room for a partitioned off dirty corner. Grinding wheel dust needs to be kept as far as possible away from your (nicely oiled) tools.

Clive

Racer Al

Stainless
Joined
Feb 20, 2006
Location
Oakland, California, USA
  • Nov 11, 2008
  • #11

One of the biggest "forward steps" I made in grinding HSS was to build a new pair of rests for my bench grinder. They are quite large, about 4" square, with a deep, tight fitting notch cut out for the wheel. The new rests wind up being vaguely "C" shaped.

The larger rest accommodates the whole tool, making it much easier to keep the desired angle.

My grinder is an older Craftsman model, and had fairly stout rests, so I just welded the new tables to the existing rests. Skimpy rests should be abandoned completely, and new rests fabricated with stout materials.

M

Mike C.

Diamond
Joined
Nov 25, 2004
Location
Birmingham, AL
  • Nov 13, 2008
  • #12

In addition to Clive's advice on the SB fixture, simply grind the bits IN the holder. If you take the bit out of the holder for grinding, you have a totally different set of angles to deal with (unless you use T type, with no rake). If you leave the bit in the holder, it makes the angles obvious and natural. Once you have the proper angles, remove the tool and use it as a pattern for hand grinding without the holder, if you wish. Holder also saves fingers from heat, lol.

After a while, you will find you probably won't even use the rests, except as a locator. It's pretty easy to hand grind lathe bits and drills without a rest at all.

B

bronto48

Hot Rolled
Joined
Apr 28, 2006
Location
Laytonsville, Maryland
  • Nov 17, 2008
  • #13

Yes, grind the bits in the fixture (talking classic Williams or Armstrong tool bit holder). The advice about having several dedicated grinders is also good, and what I have figured out also. Makes regrinding fun, not a chore.

I went into "overkill" mode a couple years ago and bought a used Baldor carbide grinder with appropriate wheels to grind my HSS bits. What a pleasure, and it made quick work of re-grinding. With the availability of the cheapo Horror Freight carbide grinders, the cost of this "luxury" way to grind ordinary HSS bits becomes manageable. With it I find I spend less time at this task.

BTW, I gave up on carbide bits some years ago. My 10L is really not heavy enough to effectively use carbide. I find that cutting edge life is generally poor and ordinary HSS usually works better for anything I am doing (aluminum, brass, steel, stainless).

Q

quasi

Stainless
Joined
Dec 18, 2003
Location
Calgary, Alberta, Canada
  • Nov 17, 2008
  • #14

for white wheels for H.S.S., I buy them from Lee Valley.

You must log in or register to reply here.

Tool sharpening, type of grinders and stones (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Nathanael Baumbach

Last Updated:

Views: 6360

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (55 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Nathanael Baumbach

Birthday: 1998-12-02

Address: Apt. 829 751 Glover View, West Orlando, IN 22436

Phone: +901025288581

Job: Internal IT Coordinator

Hobby: Gunsmithing, Motor sports, Flying, Skiing, Hooping, Lego building, Ice skating

Introduction: My name is Nathanael Baumbach, I am a fantastic, nice, victorious, brave, healthy, cute, glorious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.